Wille, M., Banyard, A.C., Bonfante, F. et al. Evidence of widespread sequencing errors in global avian influenza study. Nat Commun 17, 11335 (2026)
Wannigama et al. (2025) present a study whereby guano samples from infrequently sampled countries were assessed for the presence of avian influenza viruses. Samples were collected from Africa (Madagascar, Mozambique, Somalia), the Middle East (Yemen), South Asia (Maldives, Sri Lanka), South East Asia (Indonesia, Myanmar, the Philippines) and Oceania (Papua New Guinea). The study aims to address critical gaps in global surveillance and provide important data that could enhance understanding of regional viral diversity and evolution, as well as inform high pathogenicity avian influenza (HPAI) incursion risk assessments. However, the data presented and the conclusions drawn from this study are of high concern to the global influenza community. The viral sequence data on which the study is based contradict long-established understanding of global avian influenza evolution, resulting in conclusions that are incongruent with the global evidence base. The publication of erroneous viral sequences in public databases such as GenBank or GISAID hinders rational interpretation of data in a global context, resulting in misleading conclusions that affect disease risk assessments and policy decisions.
A consistently incongruent finding from the study is that the viral hemagglutinin (HA) and neuraminidase (NA) sequences recovered from disparate regions over prolonged time periods share 100% nucleotide identity. This level of genetic conservation is implausible for influenza A viruses, a group of rapidly evolving, negative-sense RNA viruses with a “clock-like” rate of evolution ranging from 1.8 to 8.4 × 10?3 nucleotide substitutions per site per year, with an average of 2-3 mutations for each replicated genome. These mutation rates lead to continuous genetic variation, even among viruses circulating in the same region or host population, making the detection of 100% identical viruses in wild birds across different continents and years highly unlikely. Detailed analysis of the sequences generated in this study reveals patterns inconsistent with the expected evolutionary trajectories of avian influenza viruses, with a number of examples presented here.
A holistic analysis of the NA sequences of HPAI H5N1 viruses collected in Asia since 1996 reveals the sequences in Wannigama et al. (2025) to be clear outliers. A root-to –tip regression and scatterplot of residuals obtained from aTempEst5 analysis (Fig. 1A) clearly demonstrates that the NA sequences A/feces/Papua_New_Guinea/ID_040/2021 (EPI_ISL_19613364), A/feces/Indonesia/ID_074/2022 (EPI_ISL_19613399), A/feces/Sri_Lanka/ID_170/2021 (EPI_ISL_19613510) are outliers, indicative of improbable evolutionary stasis.
A consistently incongruent finding from the study is that the viral hemagglutinin (HA) and neuraminidase (NA) sequences recovered from disparate regions over prolonged time periods share 100% nucleotide identity. This level of genetic conservation is implausible for influenza A viruses, a group of rapidly evolving, negative-sense RNA viruses with a “clock-like” rate of evolution ranging from 1.8 to 8.4 × 10?3 nucleotide substitutions per site per year, with an average of 2-3 mutations for each replicated genome. These mutation rates lead to continuous genetic variation, even among viruses circulating in the same region or host population, making the detection of 100% identical viruses in wild birds across different continents and years highly unlikely. Detailed analysis of the sequences generated in this study reveals patterns inconsistent with the expected evolutionary trajectories of avian influenza viruses, with a number of examples presented here.
A holistic analysis of the NA sequences of HPAI H5N1 viruses collected in Asia since 1996 reveals the sequences in Wannigama et al. (2025) to be clear outliers. A root-to –tip regression and scatterplot of residuals obtained from aTempEst5 analysis (Fig. 1A) clearly demonstrates that the NA sequences A/feces/Papua_New_Guinea/ID_040/2021 (EPI_ISL_19613364), A/feces/Indonesia/ID_074/2022 (EPI_ISL_19613399), A/feces/Sri_Lanka/ID_170/2021 (EPI_ISL_19613510) are outliers, indicative of improbable evolutionary stasis.
See Also:
Latest articles in those days:
- Weekly US Influenza Surveillance Report: Key Updates for Week 45, ending November 14, 2026 11 hours ago
- Anatomical Compartmentalization in Chickens Drives Divergent H9N2 Influenza Evolution Toward Human Receptor Binding and Immune Escape 1 days ago
- Epidemiologic Variability and Clinical Severity Across 11 Influenza Seasons in Children 2 days ago
- Molecular Epidemiology of Clade 2.3.4.4b H5N1 High-Pathogenicity Avian Influenza in South Africa, 2025-2026 2 days ago
- Structural basis of avian-to-human receptor-binding adaptation in H9Ny influenza A virus hemagglutinin 2 days ago
[Go Top] [Close Window]


