Colombo RE, Richard SA, Schmidt K, Schofield C, Ga. Randomized pragmatic trial of the comparative effectiveness of chicken egg-based inactivated, mammalian cell-culture-based inactivated, and recombinant protein quadrivalent seasonal influenza vaccines. Clin Infect Dis. 2025 Sep 18:ciaf503
Background: Influenza is a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. The Pragmatic Assessment of Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness (VE) in the Department of Defense (PAIVED) study compared the relative VE (rVE) of two licensed influenza vaccines (cell-culture-based inactivated influenza vaccine (ccIIV) and recombinant influenza vaccine (RIV)) to egg-based inactivated influenza vaccine (eIIV).
Methods: Between 2018-2021, PAIVED randomized (1:1:1) eligible Military Health System (MHS) beneficiaries to receive eIIV, ccIIV, or RIV during an influenza season. Participants received weekly surveys querying influenza-like illness (ILI); those reporting ILI completed an online symptom diary, were interviewed by research staff, and underwent nasal swab collection. Laboratory-confirmed influenza was the primary outcome. Immunogenicity assessment was conducted in a subset of participants.
Results: Among 15,432 participants, influenza was identified in 87/5130 (1.7%) ccIIV recipients, 79/5154 (1.5%) RIV recipients, and 69/5148 (1.3%) eIIV recipients during their season of enrollment. rVE of ccIIV compared to eIIV was -27% (95% confidence interval [CI], -73%, 8%), and rVE of RIV compared to eIIV was -14% (95% CI -58%, 17%). RIV (N=375) recipients were more likely to seroconvert (4-fold increase) than those who received eIIV (N=355) (A/H1N1: 49.1% vs 29.0%; A/H3N2: 71.2% vs 30.4%; B/Victoria 24.5% vs 13.8%; B/Yamagata 17.1% vs 5.4%; p<0.001 for all). ccIIV (N=357) recipients were more likely to seroconvert only against A/H3N2 compared to eIIV recipients (44.0% vs 30.4%) (p<0.001).
Conclusions: Significant differences in VE were not detected comparing egg-based to non-egg-based influenza vaccines, although immunogenicity differences were observed; low influenza case numbers impacted VE estimate precision.
Methods: Between 2018-2021, PAIVED randomized (1:1:1) eligible Military Health System (MHS) beneficiaries to receive eIIV, ccIIV, or RIV during an influenza season. Participants received weekly surveys querying influenza-like illness (ILI); those reporting ILI completed an online symptom diary, were interviewed by research staff, and underwent nasal swab collection. Laboratory-confirmed influenza was the primary outcome. Immunogenicity assessment was conducted in a subset of participants.
Results: Among 15,432 participants, influenza was identified in 87/5130 (1.7%) ccIIV recipients, 79/5154 (1.5%) RIV recipients, and 69/5148 (1.3%) eIIV recipients during their season of enrollment. rVE of ccIIV compared to eIIV was -27% (95% confidence interval [CI], -73%, 8%), and rVE of RIV compared to eIIV was -14% (95% CI -58%, 17%). RIV (N=375) recipients were more likely to seroconvert (4-fold increase) than those who received eIIV (N=355) (A/H1N1: 49.1% vs 29.0%; A/H3N2: 71.2% vs 30.4%; B/Victoria 24.5% vs 13.8%; B/Yamagata 17.1% vs 5.4%; p<0.001 for all). ccIIV (N=357) recipients were more likely to seroconvert only against A/H3N2 compared to eIIV recipients (44.0% vs 30.4%) (p<0.001).
Conclusions: Significant differences in VE were not detected comparing egg-based to non-egg-based influenza vaccines, although immunogenicity differences were observed; low influenza case numbers impacted VE estimate precision.
See Also:
Latest articles in those days:
- The evolution and transmission dynamics of H3N2 influenza virus identified in a respiratory disease outbreak in companion dogs in Alabama, USA 7 hours ago
- Structural and functional characterization of hemagglutinin E190D and Q226H minor variants in human H5N1 A/British Columbia/PHL-2032/2024 7 hours ago
- Spatial risk factors associated with outbreaks of highly pathogenic avian influenza in Pennsylvania’s commercial poultry farms 7 hours ago
- [preprint]H9N2 avian influenza virus in Bangladesh: three genetically distinct co-circulating subgroups retain a largely conserved antigenic phenotype 7 hours ago
- [preprint]Endogenous serine proteases in MDCK sublines support trypsin-independent influenza A virus replication 7 hours ago
[Go Top] [Close Window]


