Neutrophils play key protective roles in influenza infections, yet excessive neutrophilic inflammation is a hallmark of acute lung injury during severe infections. Phenotypic heterogeneity is increasingly recognized in neutrophil populations; however, how functional variation in neutrophils between individuals determine the diverse outcomes of influenza remains unclear. To examine immunologic responses that may drive varying outcomes in influenza, we infected C57BL/6 (B6) and A/J mice with mouse-adapted influenza A virus A/PR/8/34 H1N1. A self-resolving dose in B6 mice was lethal in A/J mice, which had increased viral load throughout infection accompanied by prominent bronchoalveolar neutrophilia and pulmonary vascular leakage preceding mortality. Notably, the B6 mice heavily recruited neutrophils to lungs early in infection while A/J mice failed to do so. Neutrophils from A/J mice additionally displayed reduced neutrophil extracellular trap (NET) release and reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation compared to B6 mice early in infection, suggesting the failure to control virus in A/J mice was a product of deficient neutrophil response. To determine if variation in neutrophils between strains governed viral control and inflammation, we adoptively transferred bone marrow neutrophils from B6 or A/J donors to A/J recipients early in infection and found that the transfer of B6 neutrophils enhanced viral clearance and abrogated the dissemination of CXCL1 and IL-6. The transfer of A/J neutrophils, however, failed to achieve either. Furthermore, B6 neutrophils were capable of greater levels of viral killing in vitro than their A/J counterparts. These results suggest that a key moderator of inflammation in influenza infection is the control of virus by neutrophils early in infection. Thus, host-specific differences in both the recruitment of these cells as well as interindividual variation in neutrophil ability to support viral clearance may in part dictate differing susceptibility to respiratory viral infections.